Questions to Ask Your Injury Lawyer During the First Meeting

Finding yourself in need of a personal injury lawyer can feel overwhelming, especially when you're still recovering from an accident. Choosing the right lawyer is a big decision, so that first meeting is crucial. It’s your chance to evaluate if they’re the best fit for your case while also clarifying your legal situation. But how do you know what to ask? Relax—I’ve got you covered. Here’s a list of important questions to ask your injury lawyer during the first meeting.

Not all injury lawyers have the same expertise. Asking about their experience with cases similar to yours gives you a sense of their capability. If your case involves a car accident, for instance, you want someone who’s handled dozens of them successfully. Ask for examples of past cases they’ve worked on and the outcomes they achieved.

Experience matters because personal injury law can get complicated, and a seasoned lawyer will know the ins and outs better than someone new to the field.

2. What’s Your Success Rate in Settlements and Trials?

Most personal injury cases settle before going to court, but that doesn’t mean trial experience isn’t important. You want a lawyer who can negotiate a fair settlement but is also ready to take the case to trial if necessary. A high success rate in both areas indicates confidence and skill.

Don’t be afraid to press for details. Ask, “How many cases like mine have you taken to trial?” or “What’s the largest settlement you’ve secured?”

3. How Will You Handle My Case Specifically?

Every case is unique, and you deserve to know how they plan to approach yours. Ask about the steps they’ll take to gather evidence, communicate with insurance companies, and build a strong argument on your behalf.

This is also the time to clarify whether they’ll personally handle your case or pass it off to a junior attorney. While working with a team isn’t necessarily bad, it’s important to know who will be your main point of contact.

4. What’s Your Fee Structure?

Understanding the lawyer’s fees upfront can save you a lot of headaches later. Most personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you win. But it’s still crucial to confirm the percentage they’ll take from your settlement or verdict.

Ask if there are additional costs for things like filing fees, expert witnesses, or document preparation. A good lawyer will be transparent about their costs, so you’re not hit with surprises.

5. How Long Will My Case Take?

While no lawyer can guarantee an exact timeline, an experienced one should give you a general idea. Factors like the complexity of your case, the willingness of the opposing party to settle, and court schedules all affect how long the process takes.

Be wary of anyone who promises a quick resolution without knowing the details of your case. A lawyer’s honesty here shows they’re realistic and won’t rush things at your expense.

6. What Can I Do to Help My Case?

A successful personal injury claim is a team effort. Ask what you can do to support your case, whether it’s providing documents, keeping a record of expenses, or avoiding certain behaviors (like posting about your accident on social media).

This question also shows the lawyer that you’re proactive and committed to getting the best outcome possible.

7. How Do You Communicate with Clients?

Clear communication is a must when working with a lawyer. Find out how often you can expect updates and the best way to reach them. Will they respond to emails or prefer phone calls? Do they use assistants or paralegals for routine communications?

A lawyer who values communication will make you feel informed and included throughout the process. If they seem dismissive or too busy, consider it a red flag.

8. What Are the Biggest Challenges in My Case?

No case is perfect, and an honest lawyer will address potential challenges upfront. Whether it’s a lack of evidence, shared liability, or dealing with a difficult insurance company, knowing the hurdles ahead helps you prepare.

A lawyer who identifies challenges early on is more likely to handle them effectively when they arise. Plus, it shows they’ve already thought critically about your case.

9. Have You Worked with My Opponent’s Insurance Company Before?

Insurance companies play a huge role in personal injury claims, and some are tougher to deal with than others. If your lawyer has experience working with the specific company involved in your case, that’s a plus.

They’ll know the company’s tactics, how they typically negotiate, and what it takes to secure a fair settlement.

10. What’s the Estimated Value of My Case?

While no lawyer can guarantee an exact amount, they should give you a ballpark figure based on their experience. Ask what factors will influence the value, like medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and long-term impacts on your life.

Keep in mind that a lawyer who promises an unrealistically high payout might be trying to win your business. Look for someone who offers a fair, reasoned estimate instead.

11. What Happens If We Don’t Win?

It’s not fun to think about losing, but it’s important to know what happens if your case doesn’t go your way. Will you owe the lawyer anything? Are there other options to pursue compensation?

Most contingency fee agreements mean you won’t pay legal fees if you lose, but it’s always good to confirm.

12. Why Should I Choose You Over Other Lawyers?

This might feel like a bold question, but it’s entirely fair. Their answer will give you insight into what sets them apart, whether it’s their experience, negotiation skills, or dedication to clients.

A confident lawyer will be happy to explain why they’re the right choice for your case. If they stumble over this question, it might be a sign to keep looking.

That first meeting with a personal injury lawyer is your opportunity to get clarity, set expectations, and build trust. By asking the right questions, you’ll feel more confident in your choice and better prepared to move forward.

Remember, a good lawyer isn’t just someone with experience—they’re someone who listens, communicates, and genuinely cares about getting you the best outcome. Take your time, trust your instincts, and don’t settle for less than you deserve.